The Buxa Tiger Controversy: Doars Rani’s Story Highlights Human Incompetence – And We Should Be Ashamed
The ordeal of Doars Rani, a tigress relocated from Bihar’s Valmiki Tiger Reserve to West Bengal’s Buxa Tiger Reserve, has exposed serious shortcomings in the planning and execution of wildlife conservation efforts. From repeated tranquillisation and a reported miscarriage to her escape from an inadequate enclosure, her story is a sobering reminder of how human incompetence can come at nature’s expense.
WILDLIFE
DEEPUNGSU PANDIT
11/17/20267 min read


The recent ordeal surrounding Doars Rani and the authorities’ troubled attempts to relocate her to the Buxa Tiger Reserve has left me deep in thought.
The incident involves a pregnant tigeress named Doars Rani, who has been tranquilised thrice in just over a month, including twice within four days!
All this trouble because the government wants to add to the tiger population in the fabled Buxa Tiger Reserve, one that had driven out its tigers due to administrative shortcomings, encroachment and a general lack of interest in conservation.
But of course, simply adding a tiger won’t suffice. There had been a solitary adult male tiger photographed in Buxa in December 2021, but the 2022 All India Tiger Estimation failed to record a tiger through camera trapping in the reserve. As such, the plan was to introduce two tigresses to build a population over time. Beautiful thoughts, but the execution is so horrid that it will leave you aghast.
A comedy of errors involving incompetence of epic proportions
As part of the process, a three-year-old tigress is tranquilised in Valmiki Tiger Reserve, Bihar and taken to the Gorakhpur airbase in Uttar Pradesh. She is then flown to Buxa.
When the tigress finally arrived at Buxa, it was observed that she had various injuries to her paw pads, nose and teeth, making it necessary to tranquilise her once again, within a span of four days.
She was then released into the wild in the presence of dignitaries, marking a new chapter in the illustrious history of Buxa Tiger Reserve in Alipurduar. The ceremony was held on October 2, but the tiger reportedly left its enclosure and moved to the jungles on October 4.
If the wildlife enthusiasts of North Bengal expected that to be the end of the story, they were in for a surprise.
Doars Rani turned out to be a true vagabond, a pilgrim drenched in wanderlust. Pretty soon, she had left Buxa behind, displaying an alarming lack of gratitude for the aristocratic welcome, and crossed over to the Raimona National Park in Assam.


The proposed crown jewel of the West Bengal government soon became a cause of embarrassment, while, Assam, the ever-gracious host, welcomed her with open arms.
Owner’s envy, neighbour’s pride?
Anyway, the diplomatic issues were eventually set aside and the tigress was monitored for the next couple of weeks. However, when she began wandering dangerously close to human settlement in the neighbouring state, Doars Rani was tranquilised (for the third time in just over a month) and brought back to Buxa.
Unfortunately, that was hardly the end of her ordeal!
On her return to Buxa, the tigress was reportedly housed in an enclosure meant to contain deer. Let that sink in. A tigress was kept in a cage that was only strong enough to contain deers. Of course, the inevitable happened and she escaped once again!
An embarrassing episode in Indian Wildlife Conservation history
The entire saga turned out to be an encyclopaedia of incompetence, but it has now raised questions about coordination between various government departments. Doars Rani’s second journey, meanwhile, has brought to light some uncomfortable truths.
According to reports, the tigress was approximately two months pregnant and suffered a miscarriage!
Three foetuses have reportedly been discovered in the enclosure, although experts are investigating the matter, adding to the wildlife enthusiasts’ frustrations. For the record, tigers have a gestation period of approximately 100–110 days.
Meanwhile, the National Tiger Conservation Authority (NTCA) have already conducted an assessment and revealed their findings. It has also confirmed that the presence of two dead foetuses. It has also insisted on being consulted before any major decision concerning Doars Rani is taken. Its preliminary findings have already corroborated some of the earlier reports, particularly those concerning the inadequacies of the enclosure..
What the entire episode has exposed is the incompetence of the human race.
An investigation will now examine whether the tigress was injured when she was captured, whether she was pregnant when she was captured, whether the three instances of tranquilisations were justified, whether there were other lapses in the process and so on and so forth.
We have become a civilisation that has developed a habit of fighting fire instead of preventing it. We take pride in seeking a cure than investing in the very prevention measures which we preach to be superior.
What could have been done?


It is not hard to imagine how the entire fiasco could have been handled better. For starters, the entire process should have been approached like a sensitive, top-priority project.
Once the tigress had been identified in Valmiki Tiger Reserve, she should have been monitored regularly in her natural habitat to assess her behaviour, and determine whether she was fit enough to withstand the journey from Valmiki to Buxa.
That would have also enabled the authorities to investigate whether she was pregnant. Wildlife experts suggest that it is hard to ascertain pregnancy in tigers, but perhaps a longer period of observation, combined with appropriate veterinary assessments, could have helped instead of rushing to fulfil administrative timelines.
You cannot carry out conservation based on human deadlines. Nature does not follow the arbitrary rules imposed by mankind.
Meanwhile, once the initial monitoring at Valmiki was complete, greater care should have been taken during transportation. Reports indicate that the flight took almost two-and-a-half hours instead of the estimated 45 minutes, which may have added to Doars Rani’s distress.


After such an ordeal, the tigress should have been afforded time to settle into her new surroundings instead of being rushed out the door in the name of conservation.
Questions arise about where the priorities lay during the entire operation. Was the forest department trying to successfully reintroduce the queen of the forest or simply adhering to the whims and fancies of those setting the administrative agenda?
Once she was released, it was clear that the tigress would need time to settle down. Perhaps the possibility of an escape from Buxa and subsequent entry into the Raimona National Park should have been considered as well? The success of every operation depends on a variety of things, and assessing the risks involved plays a crucial part.
And, then, of course, there is the matter of the three instances of tranquilisation in just over a month. Whether that contributed to the miscarriage can only be established by experts, but I think we can all agree that what unfolded in Buxa was not ideal and painted a very poor picture of man’s ability to conserve nature.
It is true that we have come a long way from the 1411, the crucial number that kickstarted a massive quest to preserve these magnificent beasts in India. Official figures from the All India Tiger Estimation carried out in 2022 suggest that India now has an estimated 3682 tigers in the wild. Perhaps three more lives could have been added to the country’s already remarkable tiger population had the operation been handled with greater care.
Doars Rani provides hope
Even in the darkest of days, however, hope is not too far away. After a freezing night, hope feels like sitting on a sunlit lawn on a winter morning, your face bathed in the golden rays.
Amid all the doom and gloom, a glimmer of hope has arrived from the unlikeliest of sources – the tigress herself. The update from the weekend suggests that Doars Rani has killed a wild boar in Buxa, generating cautious optimism that she could be settling into her new home.
On Monday, it was revealed that she had made a second kill, a sambar deer.
The authorities are now adopting a more sensible approach – they have taken a step back. Human beings tend to forget that we are not gods, that we know very little about the way of the wild. Sometimes allowing nature to take its course with minimal interference is the best conservation plan.


For now, investigations are ongoing and a further blame game is expected. There were reported plans to bring a male tiger to Buxa from Valmiki before the end of the year to aid in the “conservation process”, but that has been put on hold. Perhaps the entire incident has knocked some sense into the heads of the authorities and made them realise that nature does not follow any timelines.
In the midst of all this, Doars Rani is slowly finding her feet in North Bengal. Whether she stays in Buxa or roams around in Raimona, all we can hope for is that she recovers her health and adds life to the wilderness.
This entire world is her home and the queen cannot be confined to boundaries set by man.
Instead, it is time to trust Mother Nature to sort out this mess. In time, perhaps the pangs of despair will give way to flowers of hope and love. New life will take the place of the ones that were tragically lost. The jungle will be rife with the soft sounds of tiger cubs enjoying the warmth of their mother.
Only then will Buxa Tiger Reserve truly become Doars Rani’s home.

